Independent Jewelry Reviews & Expert Buying Advice
CaratAdvice.com
Value Diamond Buying

Blue Nile vs Costco

An unusual but genuinely relevant comparison: Costco's in-warehouse diamond counters and online jewelry section are known for thin margins, while Blue Nile offers far more selection and customization.

Blue Nile Costco
Selection size Very large Limited
Membership required No Yes

Bottom line

Tie — depends on priorities